gamemania

MEGA 44 thermal paste round-up
PDF Print E-mail
Sunday, 15 February 2009 22:00
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Article Index
MEGA 44 thermal paste round-up
Testing Methodology
Pastes tested
Testing results
Conclusion
All Pages

Thermal pastes have always been something that could give you an advantage and better performance over the stock paste.

We have seen many pastes, ceramique/silver/diamond/metal based that promise better temps!

So...what they really do?


  • For testing the pastes, I have used a 230w peltier in order to have a high thermal load and make the differences bigger and noticeable.
  • Room temp was at 24 dergees always
  • Coolermaster V8 with Nanoxia 12cm fan@1800rpm was used
  • Temps were taken from a copper plate between peltier and cooler(simulating a typical cpu heatspreader)
  • Temps were taken with a digital IR thermometer for accuracy
  • Before every new paste everything was cleaned with alcohol
  • For every paste I have done the break-in time as was specified by the manufacturer
  • Each reading was taken 5 times to ensure accuracy, if anything abnormal was noticed the test was done from the beginning. 

 


 

The thermal pastes used in the test are:



  1. Coollaboratory Liquid Pro
  2. IC Diamond
  3. Noctua NT-H1
  4. OCZ Freezer Extreme
  5. CoolerMaster Thermalfusion 400
  6. Scythe Thermal Elixer
  7. Shin Etsu X23
  8. Arctic Silver 5
  9. Zerotherm ZT-100
  10. Thermalright Chill Factor 2
  11. Arctic Cooling MX-2
  12. Gelid GC-1
  13. CoolerMaster NanoFusion
  14. OCZ Ultra 5+
  15. Thermalright Chill Factor
  16. Nexus paste
  17. Coolink ChillaRamic
  18. Arctic Ceramique
  19. Zalman ZM-STG1
  20. CoolerMaster IceFusion
  21. Spire Stars-700
  22. Cooljag paste
  23. Vantec paste
  24. CoolerMaster Premium grease
  25. Thermaltage TG-1
  26. Antec Thermal paste
  27. Arctic Silver adhesive
  28. Arctic Alumina
  29. Zalman Thermal Grease
  30. Xilence Silver Tim
  31. Asetek Thermal paste
  32. Akasa Hi-Performance 460
  33. StarTech SilverGrease1
  34. Evercool Sidewinder
  35. Thermaltake TG-2
  36. Silmore Gray
  37. Thermoflex
  38. CoolSilver paste
  39. Liquid Metal Pad
  40. Spire SP420
  41. StarTech paste
  42. Silmore White
  43. Thermaltake grease
  44. VIO thermal grease 

 


The results can be viewed here

 

 

 

 

 

 


The best thermal compound proved to be the Coollaboratory Liquid Pro, followed by IC Diamond and Noctua NT-H1.

 

Differences are not so noticable because all surfaces were perfectly lapped.Cpu's and heatinks don't have so well lapped contact surfaces, so the real life differences will probably be bigger.This happens because if the surfaces are very well lappe, thermal paste is just to fill tiny gaps, but if the surfaces are rough then paste has to fill much more space, and if it has not good thermal conductivity differences are more noticable. 

The purpose of this round-up was to compare the 44 pastes under the exactly same conditions to find out which one performs better.

In fact the most limiting factor is the cpu and heatsink contact surfaces, and the thermal paste by its own.A well lapped cpu heatspreader and heatsink can help to get better temperatures even and with mid-range thermal pastes.

 

So...if you want the best out of your cooler, you must choose one of these!

 

Any feedback from you is greatly appreciated, for any comments or recommendations you can contact me by using the Contact Us form.

 

And the awards...!

 

                                                                 Coollaboratory Liquid Pro

                                                      "For the highest performance and innovation"

 


 

 


 
 
 
 
 
 
                                                                          IC Diamond

                                                         "For high performance and innovation"

 

 

 

 

                                                                      Noctua NT-H1

                                                       "For performance and quick break-in time"

 

 

 

 


 

 

UPDATE 11/3/2009

A new round-up will follow, only with the 5 top performing pastes using numerous heat loads from 45 to 400 watts.

Stay tuned Wink Wink Unfortunately it is not possible to further test the pastes with higher thermal loads, because even watercooling cannot handle such load.

 



Last Updated on Saturday, 07 November 2009 11:13
 

Editor's Picks

  • Noctua NH-D14 Noctua which is well known for the performance,quality and low noise of its products has released the new NH-D14 cpu cooler... Review
  • Arctic Cooling Accelero Xtreme Plus Probably the best vga cooler in the market, both in performance and noise... Review
  • Spakle Calibre X265 Calibre series focus on two things, high performance and nice aesthetics. ... Review
  • GlacialPower GP-AX950AA The new high end power supply from GlacialPower that can deliver up to 950 watts of power and is also 80 plus Silver certified ... Review